The complete review
What should I check before publishing AI-assisted marketing copy?
Check generic wording, supported claims, differentiation, proof and specifics, opening strength, CTA quality, brand voice, and visual authenticity. Score each criterion 0, 1, or 2. A strong piece earns 13–16. Anything below 9 needs another substantive pass, not synonym swapping.
01Generic wording
2: Language belongs to this company and offer. 1: A few replaceable phrases. 0: A competitor could publish it unchanged.
02Supported claims
2: Every meaningful claim has evidence or careful qualification. 1: Proof is implied. 0: Superlatives or outcomes appear without support.
03Differentiation
2: Names a concrete mechanism, constraint, or tradeoff. 1: Category benefits dominate. 0: No reason to choose this offer.
04Proof and specifics
2: Uses a real number, named example, quote, or dated moment. 1: One broad example. 0: Entirely abstract.
05Opening strength
2: Starts on a specific tension or useful open loop. 1: Clear but predictable. 0: Warm-up, throat-clearing, or category filler.
06Call to action
2: One specific, proportionate next step. 1: A generic action. 0: Missing, competing, or disconnected CTA.
07Brand voice
2: Matches phrases and convictions the brand actually uses. 1: Competent but neutral. 0: Performs an invented personality.
08Visual authenticity
2: Visual direction shows the real product, process, or evidence. 1: Relevant but generic. 0: Glossy AI imagery substitutes for proof.